The Future of Silent Hill is Once Again in Question

Published by Nick Henderson on March 24, 2015

og:image, Silent Hills, Konami, Hideo Kojima, Not Like This

Many people have asked me what I think about this whole Konami and Kojima situation. Let me start with a message to Konami...

“Dear Konami,

Silent Hill, much like Metal Gear Solid, has been fan favorite and one of the driving forces behind your continued success as a game publisher. Sure, you have plenty of other properties but these two franchises have long been considered among the best in their respective genres… So please… PLEASE… PLEEEAAASSSEEEE Stop treating Silent Hill like your least favorite child!

You have gotten away with this for too long and have only managed to keep the franchise afloat by putting him in the care of moderately experienced babysitters. You even spat in our face by releasing a broken HD Collection. Restore some faith and show some confidence in your project and your team by pushing forward even IF Kojima’s involvement ends. You surprised a lot of people when you launched PT and all we want is to see that project come to fruition so that it can be played and judged on it’s own merits.

I guess what i’m trying to say is… don’t f*** this up… again… especially if you ever want my money again.

Temporarily Yours,

Nick’s Wallet

Since it’s announcement, Silent Hills has very much been at the forefront of my thoughts when it comes to gaming. It inspired me to return to this storied franchise and play it all again, blemishes and all. In fact, the day it was revealed that Hideo Kojima and Guillermo Del Toro would be putting their heads together, I knew I could die happy. In fact, PT was good enough on it’s own that it landed a spot in my Top 10 last year. Considering all this, it is easy to imagine my shock at the news this week that Hideo Kojima is rumored to be leaving Konami after the release of Metal Gear Solid V.

I don’t mean to delve into the reasoning of this decision or the events going on behind the scenes at Konami right now because lord knows we’ll go there on tonight’s podcast. All we know is that Konami appears to have removed Kojima’s name from marketing materials and rebranding Kojima Productions as an LA based Konami studio. Many people are up in arms about what this might mean for the future of Metal Gear Solid and rightfully so. With that said, my fears fall more in the realm of Silent Hill for a couple of reasons.

  • Metal Gear Solid has had a long and consistently positive life. Not to imply that I wouldn’t want more but Kojima himself has implied that he desires to retire from the franchise for years. On top of that, it would be great to let the “Solid” franchise end on a high note. For that reason, i’m not too sad about the thought of this being Kojima’s last Metal Gear. Konami has also already expressed their intention to continue the series beyond the release of MGSV with or without Kojima. 
  • Silent Hill on the other hand has had a long and perilous life that has run the gamut from extreme high’s to what some might argue to be dramatic lows. While I have enjoyed some of the less popular entries in the series more than most, it’s still a franchise that I think deserves better. At the very least, it deserves one last game that can let it relive it’s glory days before being sent out to pasture.

At this point, my fear is that Konami might cancel the project entirely before it ever sees the light of day. With that said, I would guess that Konami has passed the point of no return by releasing PT in 2014 because the fan reaction to that was pretty damn impressive. Even without Kojima’s involvement, it would be a foolish move to cancel the project. Let’s not forget that Kojima is not the only creative force at Konami and nobody really knows what influence he really had on that demo anyways.

I hate to say it, but this may be another “Mercury Steam in association with Kojima Productions” situation. This is especially possible given the fact that he has been so busy finishing up Metal Gear. We’ll go into detail about this topic on tonight’s podcast and what it means for both Metal Gear and Silent Hill, as well as what it means for the company in general.

Tune in to tonight at 8:30PM (CST) to hear our thoughts or download the show when it hits iTunes later in the week!


  • Avatar
    5 years, 4 months ago

    Seeing as how Silent Hill is one of my favorite franchises of all time I was upset by this news, This is just another example of these company's not learning from mistakes (and Konami has made quite a lot of them), I hope Silent Hills is great but my expectations weren't high to begin with and this announcement doesn't help. My faith in this industry is already hanging by a thread , with AAA company's constant mistakes, overly priced microtransactions, games being released that aren't even finished, publisher's buying good reviews,etc... I see myself shaking my head thinking what could possibly happen next? Who knows.

  • Shazza1990 Avatar
    5 years, 4 months ago

    Great letter, pretty much sums up my feelings.

    Silent Hill, SH2 to be exact, is what me got me into the more serious side of gaming in terms of story and location. It was the first game I was playing for the story just as much as the scares it brought. I was extremely disappointed in SH Homecoming and though I felt it was an improvement, I still wasn't so hot on SH Downpour either. I was waiting for a return to some genuine shit your pants moments from this series... and that arrived with P.T. Nothing in any game or movie has creeped me out like that teaser. I try to not have high hopes, but it's hard with the series I love so much.