If you have ever played an online game, chances are you have encountered quite a few unpleasant or down right obnoxious people. I don't mean the type of people who blast music through their headsets, but more the ones who love insulting other players or dropping slurs every 5 seconds. Unsurprisingly, this leaves anyone with even a shred of maturity or self control to be turned off from online gaming entirely or forces them to simply mute whatever chat system the game uses. Even worse is the fact that most game companies really don't do anything, or just not enough, to stop this kind of behavior. Of course, League of Legends, was no exception to this, but Riot has stepped up and added new features in an attempt to reel in these kinds of players.

The first of these features implemented is called The Tribunal. Basically, anyone who has been reported several times for foul language, leaving a game, or just general trolling will have a Trbunal case created for them on the Leagoe of Legends website. Each case is presented with usually 2-6 instances of when the player was reported and includes full chat logs for each game, the date for the game, the type and match length, as well as the items and K/D/A the player had by the end of the game. You are given 20 seconds before you can vote in each case and,if your judgement is in line with the judgement of other players, you will be given a small reward of in-game currency. Should a majority of players find someone guilty of breaking "The Summoner's Code", then the case is forwarded to a team at Riot who determine what the punishment shall be for the rule breaker.

The next step Riot made to ensuring all players behave themselves was the "Honor Player" system. After a game, you are given the option to reward a player for their behavior. There are four categories that you can place one point into after a game: helpful, friendly, teamwork, or honorable opponent. Gather enough of these points and you will earn a green (for good team player) or red (for honorable opponent) banner around your profile name that appears both in-character select and the loading screen for both teams to see. Because of the fact that your Honor points will reset should the Tribunal ever find you guilty, this sends a clear message to the community that these players really do go out of their way to be cooperative or polite. You may be thinking "a little banner around my profile name doesn't seem like much of a reward", but you would be surprised by how many players do try to acquire it.

Both of these systems rely on one aspect that really makes them unique: the players themselves enforce the rules that Riot has created and judge players who don't follow them. Not even well-known or professional League of Legends players are given much leeway when it comes to these systems. Just recently, a professional player "IWillDominate", was banned from the game after he was found guilty in the Tribunal 8 out of the 9 seperate cases that were brought up. The fact that Riot Games is willing to punish their most high profile players gives me a tremendous amount respect for them. The decision to harshly punish one of the players that represents their game and participates in most major tournaments could not have been an easy one to make, but I'm glad they did.

So, what can we learn from all this? Well, firstly, that not all players of online games are obnoxious. Given the right incentive, most players will be willing to cooperate and be civil with one another. What is even better is that this proves that you do not need large reward to encourage this behavior either; a shiny banner is really all you need apparently. The fact that all of this is also run by players means that people are willing to enforce a game's rule set even without a way to exploit these systems for easy rewards. I really feel this shows more developers of online games need to take an active role in enforcing good conduct. This does not mean monitoring every player 24/7 or being ban happy, but a player run system with small rewards that cannot be exploited really seems like the ideal way of handling online communities. I really do hope this will become a trend that finds its way into more and more games. I am sure that most of us have played a game that could benefit from this.

Comments

  • Avatar
    SonicKitsune
    11 years, 5 months ago

    As little as I care about League of Legends itself, it's an interesting system of justice.

  • Avatar
    wrapper
    11 years, 5 months ago

    As promising as it sounds, in my experience the Tribunal is an inherently flawed system that ruins the game for anyone who plays it often enough. While I personally am a casual League of Legends player, and a person who usually avoids conflict, I am yet to experience a punishment from this system. I personally know, however, several players from the League of Legends professional scene who have been banned by the tribunal for little to no reason (including a permanent suspension). Having actually reviewed the report tickets in several cases (the system gives you this opportunity after a punishment), I can honestly say I haven't seen any basis for a suspension. The sad truth is that the game has a terrible community, and it is a mistake to rely on it to deliver 'justice' to players.

  • lostking Avatar
    lostking
    11 years, 5 months ago

    the issue here is that in giving the whole community power, you're giving the majority of LoL player (the dicks) the chance to abuse it.

  • Avatar
    Mustard
    11 years, 5 months ago

    You guys are aware that most of the players who end up punished on tribunal actually deserved it right? Flaws exist in ALL systems of any kind. If you believe you're truly innocent, you can make a grievance or raise a ticket to Riot, and they have in the past lifted bans, or reviewed cases themselves and agreed with the result.

    In fact a pro player got banned for being sent to tribunal numerous times, and he truly was toxic.

    The whole idea that "all of LoL community are dicks" is also false. The dicks aren't necessarily the majority, however they are the LOUDEST. It works the same with any extremists for any group. It's like stereotypes and such.

    Also, the tribunal works well against dicks. Its a simple system, if you report cases, and most of your reports end up being pardons, you lose credibility in the system. Same works for voting for punish and pardon. The more cases you get wrong, the lower the credibility of your individual vote gets.

    Now, assuming majority rule is true, let's not forget that most big cases that are perma bans are reviewed by Riot. Anything bigger than a 1 week ban is reviewed by Riot. If you were unfairly punished, everyone who voted to punish now lose credibility. The tribunal has actually become more accurate as time went on BECAUSE of the system implemented.

    When it was first created, it was just punish punish punish. Now, most cases actually have reliable results. Of course, no system is perfect, I mean, look at current law systems.

    Honor works the same way, your honor becomes less credible if you honor people left and right. However if you only give honor for very strong displays, your honor is "worth" more.